Differences between revisions 9 and 14 (spanning 5 versions)
Revision 9 as of 2026-05-03 08:30:02
Size: 2553
Comment:
Revision 14 as of 2026-05-04 09:20:55
Size: 6197
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 4: Line 4:
 . Jamil Zaki . 2024 . 149 ZAK . Beaverton Library  . [[ https://www.jamil-zaki.com/ | Jamil Zaki ]] . 2024 . 149 ZAK . Beaverton Library
 . Dr. Zaki is professor of psychology at Stanford University and director of the [[ http://ssnl.stanford.edu/ | Stanford Social Neuroscience Lab ]]
Line 11: Line 12:
 .p001 [[ https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/02/opinion/emile-bruneau-dead.html | Emile Bruneau ]] died 2020 age 47
Line 12: Line 14:
 .p003
 .p004
 .p004
 .p005
 .p005
 .p007
 .p009
 .p009
 .p003 Emile's mother schizophrenic, but "She never let any of the darkness touch me"
 .p004 Cynicism ... is a seductive worldview, dark and simple. Too simple, really to explain much of anything.
 .p004 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Social_Survey | General Social Survey ]] began in 1972
 .p005 In 1972, 50% agreed that "most people can be trusted", only 33% agreed in 2018.
 .p005 52% trusted president in 1970s, 23% in 2022. Newspapers 39% to 18%. Public schools 58% to 28%
 .p007 Media's product is cynicism.
 .p008 Nietzche called hope "the most evil of evils because it prolongs man's torment"
 .p009 Cynicism is a lack of faith in people, skepticism is a lack of faith in our assumptions.
Line 25: Line 27:
 .p015
 .p016
 .p017
 .p018
 .p020
 .p020
 .p021
 .p021
 .p025
 .p025
 .p026
 .p026
 .p027
 .p028
 .p015 Mycroft Holmes more talented, but "no ambition and no energy" and a disdain for humanity
 .p016 Mycroft Holmes co-founded [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diogenes_Club | Diogenes Club ]]
 .p018 "big-C Cynicism" opposite of misanthropy and "small-c cynicism"
 .p017 the real [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diogenes | Diogenes ]] helped people and would despise the Diogenes Cl[[ | ]][[ | ]]ub.
 .p017 Three statement test:
  .(1) No one cares much what happens to you.
  .(2) Most people dislike helping others.
  .(3) Most people are honest chiefly through fear of getting caught.
 .p018 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cook%E2%80%93Medley_hostility_scale | Cook and Medley: ]] Worse teachers agreed with these statements. They are a "cynicism detector".
 .p020 adolescent cynics more likely depressed, drink and divorce in and after college
  . cynics earn less, more heart disease, die sooner
 .p020 Finland 58% trust, France 18% trust
 .p021 High trust nations grow GDP faster
 .p025 Dining out, bring Tupperware rather than single use plastic from restaurants (?)
 .p025 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autarky | autarkeia ]] self-sufficiency
 .p026 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-Reliance | Self-Reliance ]] 1841 essay by [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ralph_Waldo_Emerson | Ralph Waldo Emerson ]]
 .p026 Stanford's [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoffrey_L._Cohen | Geoff Cohen ]]
 .p027 people who affirm their values become more open to contradictory infomation
 .p028 Zaki was jealous of others, birth of daughters overwhelmed worries about social status
Line 42: Line 49:
 .p029
 .p030
 .p030
 .p031
 .p031
 .p035
 .p039
 .p042
 .p043
 .p043
 .p044
 .p045
 .p030 valorize: enhance value
 .p030 cynics wise less often, poor at identifying liars
 .p031 [[ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29993325/ | the cynical genius illusion ]]
 .p031 real wisdom when people know what they ''don't'' know. Think more like a skeptical scientist, less like a accusing lawyer
 .p035 [[ | ]]
 .p039 [[ | ]]
 .p042 [[ | ]]
 .p043 [[ | ]]
 .p043 [[ | ]]
 .p044 [[ | ]]
 .p045 [[ | ]]
Line 56: Line 62:
 .'''p046 Chapter 3. Preexisting Conditions'''
 .p047
 .p049
 .p050

 .p051
 .p052
 .p053
 .p053
 .p054

 .p060
 .p061
 .'''p046 Chapter 3. Preexisting Conditions'''[[ | ]]
 .p047 [[ | ]]
 .p049 [[ | ]]
 .p050 [[ | ]]

 .p051 [[ | ]]
 .p052 [[ | ]]
 .p053 [[ | ]]
 .p053 [[ | ]]
 .p054 [[ | ]]

 .p060 [[ | ]]
 .p061 [[ | ]]
Line 70: Line 76:
 .p069
 .p069
 .p070
 .p072
 .p072
 .p073
 .p073
 .p074
 .p075
 .p076
 .p076
 .p076
 .p076
 .p077
 .p077
 .p069 [[ | ]]
 .p069 [[ | ]]
 .p070 [[ | ]]
 .p072 [[ | ]]
 .p072 [[ | ]]
 .p073 [[ | ]]
 .p073 [[ | ]]
 .p074 [[ | ]]
 .p075 [[ | ]]
 .p076 [[ | ]]
 .p076 [[ | ]]
 .p076 [[ | ]]
 .p076 [[ | ]]
 .p077 [[ | ]]
 .p077 [[ | ]]
Line 88: Line 94:
 .p079
 .p080
 .p084
 .p089
 .p091
 .p092
 .p079 [[ | ]]
 .p080 [[ | ]]
 .p084 [[ | ]]
 .p089 [[ | ]]
 .p091 [[ | ]]
 .p092 [[ | ]]
Line 100: Line 106:
 .p097
 .p100
 .p100
 .p101
 .p102
 .p103
 .p103
 .p104
 .p105
 .p105
 .p106
 .p107
 .p107
 .p108
 .p110
 .p111
 .p113
 .p097 [[ | ]]
 .p100 [[ | ]]
 .p100 [[ | ]]
 .p101 [[ | ]]
 .p102 [[ | ]]
 .p103 [[ | ]]
 .p103 [[ | ]]
 .p104 [[ | ]]
 .p105 [[ | ]]
 .p105 [[ | ]]
 .p106 [[ | ]]
 .p107 [[ | ]]
 .p107 [[ | ]]
 .p108 [[ | ]]
 .p110 [[ | ]]
 .p111 [[ | ]]
 .p113 [[ | ]]
Line 120: Line 126:
 .p115
 .p116
 .p116
 .p118
 .p119
 .p123
 .p123
 .p125
 .p125
 .p126
 .p129
 .p115 [[ | ]]
 .p116 [[ | ]]
 .p116 [[ | ]]
 .p118 [[ | ]]
 .p119 [[ | ]]
 .p123 [[ | ]]
 .p123 [[ | ]]
 .p125 [[ | ]]
 .p125 [[ | ]]
 .p126 [[ | ]]
 .p129 [[ | ]]
Line 134: Line 140:
 .p130
 .p131
 .p136
 .p138
 .p138
 .p139
 .p142
 .p143
 .p143
 .p144
 .p145
 .p145
 .p130 [[ | ]]
 .p131 [[ | ]]
 .p136 [[ | ]]
 .p138 [[ | ]]
 .p138 [[ | ]]
 .p139 [[ | ]]
 .p142 [[ | ]]
 .p143 [[ | ]]
 .p143 [[ | ]]
 .p144 [[ | ]]
 .p145 [[ | ]]
 .p145 [[ | ]]
Line 152: Line 158:
 .p153
 .p154
 .p154
 .p155
 .p157
 .p160
 .p161
 .p165
 .p153 [[ | ]]
 .p154 [[ | ]]
 .p154 [[ | ]]
 .p155 [[ | ]]
 .p157 [[ | ]]
 .p160 [[ | ]]
 .p161 [[ | ]]
 .p165 [[ | ]]
Line 163: Line 169:
 .p171
 .p173
 .p183
 .p171 [[ | ]]
 .p173 [[ | ]]
 .p183 [[ | ]]
Line 169: Line 175:
 .p185
 .p191
 .p185 [[ | ]]
 .p191 [[ | ]]
Line 193: Line 199:
 .p262 Emile Bruneau  .p263 Emile Bruneau

Hope For Cynics

The Surprising Science of Human Goodness


  • Hope is not a lottery ticket you can sit on the couch and clutch, feeling lucky.
  • It is an axe you break down doors with in an emergency.
  • -- Rebecca Solnit


  • p001 Introduction

  • p001 Emile Bruneau died 2020 age 47

  • p001 Peace and Conflict Neuroscience Lab at U. Penn. Annenberg School for Communication (cannot find)
  • p003 Emile's mother schizophrenic, but "She never let any of the darkness touch me"
  • p004 Cynicism ... is a seductive worldview, dark and simple. Too simple, really to explain much of anything.
  • p004 General Social Survey began in 1972

  • p005 In 1972, 50% agreed that "most people can be trusted", only 33% agreed in 2018.
  • p005 52% trusted president in 1970s, 23% in 2022. Newspapers 39% to 18%. Public schools 58% to 28%
  • p007 Media's product is cynicism.
  • p008 Nietzche called hope "the most evil of evils because it prolongs man's torment"
  • p009 Cynicism is a lack of faith in people, skepticism is a lack of faith in our assumptions.


  • Section I: UNLEARNING CYNICISM


  • p015 Chapter 1. Signs and Symptoms

  • p015 Mycroft Holmes more talented, but "no ambition and no energy" and a disdain for humanity
  • p016 Mycroft Holmes co-founded Diogenes Club

  • p018 "big-C Cynicism" opposite of misanthropy and "small-c cynicism"
  • p017 the real Diogenes helped people and would despise the Diogenes Cl]][[ub.

  • p017 Three statement test:
    • (1) No one cares much what happens to you.
    • (2) Most people dislike helping others.
    • (3) Most people are honest chiefly through fear of getting caught.
  • p018 Cook and Medley: Worse teachers agreed with these statements. They are a "cynicism detector".

  • p020 adolescent cynics more likely depressed, drink and divorce in and after college
    • cynics earn less, more heart disease, die sooner
  • p020 Finland 58% trust, France 18% trust
  • p021 High trust nations grow GDP faster
  • p025 Dining out, bring Tupperware rather than single use plastic from restaurants (?)
  • p025 autarkeia self-sufficiency

  • p026 Self-Reliance 1841 essay by Ralph Waldo Emerson

  • p026 Stanford's Geoff Cohen

  • p027 people who affirm their values become more open to contradictory infomation
  • p028 Zaki was jealous of others, birth of daughters overwhelmed worries about social status


  • p029 Chapter 2. The Surprising Wisdom of Hope

  • p030 valorize: enhance value
  • p030 cynics wise less often, poor at identifying liars
  • p031 the cynical genius illusion

  • p031 real wisdom when people know what they don't know. Think more like a skeptical scientist, less like a accusing lawyer

  • p035

  • p039

  • p042

  • p043

  • p043

  • p044

  • p045


  • p046 Chapter 3. Preexisting Conditions

  • p047

  • p049

  • p050

  • p051

  • p052

  • p053

  • p053

  • p054

  • p060

  • p061


  • p065 Chapter 4. Hell Isn't Other People

  • p069

  • p069

  • p070

  • p072

  • p072

  • p073

  • p073

  • p074

  • p075

  • p076

  • p076

  • p076

  • p076

  • p077

  • p077


  • p079 Chapter 5. Escaping the Cynicism Trap

  • p079

  • p080

  • p084

  • p089

  • p091

  • p092


  • Section II: REDISCOVERING ONE ANOTHER


  • p097 Chapter 6. The (Social) Water is Just Fine

  • p097

  • p100

  • p100

  • p101

  • p102

  • p103

  • p103

  • p104

  • p105

  • p105

  • p106

  • p107

  • p107

  • p108

  • p110

  • p111

  • p113


  • p114 Chapter 7. Building Cultures of Trust

  • p115

  • p116

  • p116

  • p118

  • p119

  • p123

  • p123

  • p125

  • p125

  • p126

  • p129


  • p130 Chapter 8. The Fault in Our Fault Lines

  • p130

  • p131

  • p136

  • p138

  • p138

  • p139

  • p142

  • p143

  • p143

  • p144

  • p145

  • p145


  • Section III: THE FUTURE OF HOPE


  • p151 Chapter 9. Building the World We Want

  • p153

  • p154

  • p154

  • p155

  • p157

  • p160

  • p161

  • p165


  • p168 Chapter 10. The Optimism of Activism

  • p171

  • p173

  • p183


  • p185 Chapter 11. Our Common Fate

  • p185

  • p191



  • p200 Epilogue


  • p205 Acknowledgements


  • p209 Appendix A: A Practical Guide to Hopeful Skepticism


  • p213 Appendix B: Evaluating the Evidence


  • p217 Chapter Claim Ratings


  • p225 Notes


  • p263 Index

  • p263 Emile Bruneau

HopeForCynics (last edited 2026-05-09 22:43:13 by KeithLofstrom)