Differences between revisions 1 and 22 (spanning 21 versions)
Revision 1 as of 2026-05-02 02:03:58
Size: 1394
Comment:
Revision 22 as of 2026-05-13 00:44:56
Size: 10819
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 5: Line 5:
----- ----
Line 7: Line 7:
 .p001

------
 .'''Section I: UNLEARNING CYNICISM'''

-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - Signs and Symptoms'''
 .p015

----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - God's Own Medicine'''
 .p016 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noscapine | alpha-narcotine ]] [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Papaverine| papaverine ]] [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thebaine | thebaine ]]
 .p022 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Wood_(physician) | Alexander Wood ]] invented [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypodermic_needle | first hypodermic needle 1853 ]] to administer morphine (rather than orally), believed that injection would "cure the appetite" for morphine addiction.
  ."Pandora" repeats myth that morphine overdose injection killed his wife, who actually outlived him by 10 years.
 .p024 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinrich_Dreser | Heinrich Dreser ]] responsible for [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspirin | aspirin ]] and [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroin | heroin ]] and [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codeine | codeine ]] at [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer | Bayer AG ]]

 .p025 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eli_Lilly_and_Company| Eli Lilly ]] "safe" heroin distributed over-the-counter without prescription in the US in 1900, JAMA "standard of care" in 1906
 .p025 1906 JAMA: heroin standard of care for many respiratory ailments; by 1910 doctors aware of addiction, use declined
 .p027 next, [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thebaine | thebaine ]] a different opium compound. [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxycodone | oxycodone ]] the synthetic form in 1916,
 .p028 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purdue_Pharma | Purdue ]] [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxycodone | OxyContin ]] time release tablet releases immediate addictive dose if chewed

----
 .'''p041 Chapter 2 - The Great Margarine Mistake'''
 .p043 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancel_Keys | Ancel Keys ]] urged fat restriction
 .po44 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Senate_Select_Committee_on_Nutrition_and_Human_Needs | 1977 McGovern report ]] food guidelines authored by [[ https://www.commondreams.org/author/nick-motter | Nick Mottern ]] non-scientist reporter
 .p048 The 1977 report conflated unhealthy [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat | saturated fats ]] with healthy, essential [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsaturated_fat | unsaturated fats ]] (some double bonds between carbons)
 .p050 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margarine | margarine ]] unhealthy [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans_fat | trans-fats ]]
  . [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monounsaturated_fat | Monounsaturated fat ]] healthiest; olive oil, algal oil, and omega-3 fatty acids
 .p051 Cis-unsaturated fats (two adjacent "missing" hydrogens at a double carbon bond) are liquids because the molecules bend and don't stack into a solid
 .p052 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans_fat | Trans fat ]] molecules straight and unhealthy
 .p053 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisco | Crisco ]] '''Crys'''talized '''co'''ttonseed oil, hydrogenated
 .p054 [[ https://www.cspi.org/ | CSPI ]] Center for Science in the Public Interest
 .p054 and NHSA(?) pushed trans-fats as a healthy alternative
 .p055 replacing trans-fats with other unsaturated fats reduced heart disease by 33% (or 53%)
 .p056 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_low-density_lipoprotein | vLDL ]] worse than [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-density_lipoprotein | LDL ]], [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-density_lipoprotein | HDL ]] best
 .p056 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_Additives_Amendment_of_1958 | Food and Additives Amendment ]] grandfathered pre-1958 foods, [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Academy_of_Medicine | Institute of Medicine ]] petitioned transfat removal in 1994
 .p057 Harvard nutritionist [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Willett | Walter Willett ]] recommended margarine in 1980s, "sending them to their graves prematurely"
 .p057 2006 FDA required trans-fats on nutrition labels
 .p058 products with less than 0.5g transfat can claim 0g transfat on the nutrition label
 .p058 avoid "partially hydrogenated vegetable oil on nutrition label
 .p059 "Welsh study showed exactly the opposite" (that trans-fat was bad)

----
 .'''p061 Chapter 3 - Blood From Air'''
 .p062 farming without artificial fertilizer feeds less than 4 billion people.
 .p063 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fritz_Haber | Fritz Haber ]] 1868-1934
  .Wife [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clara_Immerwahr | Clara ]] chemist, first Phd for German woman, suicide after Fritz supervises chemical weapon attack
 .p066 1912 Germany imported 900,000 tonnes of nitrates, mostly from Chile, potential naval blockade
 .p067 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karlsruhe_Institute_of_Technology | University of Karlsruhe ]] and [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BASF | BASF ]], more German Nobel Prizes
 .p068 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triple_bond | N₂ triple bond ]] "strongest in nature" 945 kJ/mol (natural carbon monoxide 1072 kJ/mol is 50-100 ppb)
 .p070 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Le_Rossignol | Robert Le Rossignol ]] engineered first tabletop "Haber" process
 .p071 Output increase from 0.005% to 8% "logarithmically better" oopsie, should be "exponentially better"
 .p071 Industrial scaleup by [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Bosch | Carl Bosch ]], founder of [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IG_Farben | IG Farben ]]
 .p072 by 1911, 8000 pounds of ammonia per day
 .p072 1913 [[ https://www.basf.com/global/en/who-we-are/history/chronology/1902-1924/1913 | Oppau ]] plant produced 60,000 tons of ammonia per year
 .p073 "Today" 130 million tons of nitrogen fertilizer
 .p074 [[ https://www.mdpi.com/2673-3994/3/3/26 | Ammonia Production Plants—A Review ]]
 .p074 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_production#Production_plants | M.W. Kellogg ]] 1960s most efficient ammonia manufacturing
 .p074 Chinese obesity, 30% of Beijing overweight
 .p075 Donaldson Louisiana largest nitrogen producing plant, 8 million tonnes per year
 .p075 [[ https://www.ucs.org/about/news/nitrogen-farms-cause-24-billion-gulf-dead-zone-damage | dead zone ]] in Gulf of Mexico larger than New Jersey
 .p076 excess nitrogen also from food animal manure
 .p077 1914 Germany invaded neutral Belgium, Haber and 90+ other German scientists signed manifesto defending the war
 .p078 1915 Haber produces 150 T/day ammonium nitrate explosive
 .p078 1917 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leuna_works | Leuna plant ]] produced 240,000 T/y
 .p079 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Speer | Speer: ]] If Allies had focused on destroying Leuna plant, WWII could have ended in eight weeks
 .p081 1916, Haber chief of Chemical Warfare Service, 2000 scientists
 .p081 chlorine gas, immediate death, heavier than air and spreads down into trenches
 .p081 violation of 1907 [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hague_Conventions_of_1899_and_1907 | Hague Convention ]], signed by Germany
 .p082 Haber releases 150 tonnes of chlorine near 1915 Ypres, witnessed by future Nobel Prize winners [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_Hahn | Otto Hahn, ]] [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustav_Ludwig_Hertz | Gustav Hertz, ]] [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Franck | James Franck, ]] and [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Geiger | Hans Geiger ]]
 .p083 Haber's chemist wife [[ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clara_Immerwahr | Clara, ]] first Phd for German woman, suicide after Fritz supervises chemical weapon attack
 .p084 [[ | ]]
 .p085 [[ | ]]
 .p086 [[ | ]]
 .p086 [[ | ]]
 .p087 [[ | ]]
 .p088 [[ | ]]
 .p090 [[ | ]]
 .p091 [[ | ]]
 .p092 [[ | ]]
 .p094 [[ | ]]

----
 .'''p097 Chapter 4 America's Master Race'''
 .p097 [[ | ]]
 .p098 [[ | ]]
 .p098 [[ | ]]
 .p100 [[ | ]]
 .p101 [[ | ]]
 .p103 [[ | ]]
 .p104 [[ | ]]Support
 .p105 [[ | ]]
 .p107 [[ | ]]
 .p107 [[ | ]]
 .p108 [[ | ]]
 .p109 [[ | ]]
 .p111 [[ | ]]
 .p112 [[ | ]]
 .p116 [[ | ]]
 .p118 [[ | ]]
 .p121 [[ | ]]
 .p121 [[ | ]]
 .p121 [[ | ]]
 .p122 [[ | ]]
 .p122 [[ | ]]
 .p122 [[ | ]]
 .p123 [[ | ]]
 .p124 [[ | ]]
 .p125 [[ | ]]
 .p125 [[ | ]]
 .p127 [[ | ]]
 .p128 [[ | ]]
 .p129 [[ | ]]

----
 .'''p131 Chapter 5 - Turning the Mind Inside Out'''
 .p132 [[ | ]]
 .p134 [[ | ]]
 .p135 [[ | ]]
 .p136 [[ | ]]
 .p138 [[ | ]]
 .p146 [[ | ]]
 .p147 [[ | ]]
 .p147 [[ | ]]
 .p148 [[ | ]]
 .p148 [[ | ]]
 .p148 [[ | ]]
 .p148 [[ | ]]
 .p149 [[ | ]]
 .p150 [[ | ]]
 .p151 [[ | ]]
 .p152 [[ | ]]
 .p152 [[ | ]]
 .p153 [[ | ]]
 .p153 [[ | ]]
 .p153 [[ | ]]
 .p154 [[ | ]]
 .p154 [[ | ]]
 .p155 [[ | ]]
 .p155 [[ | ]]
 .p156 [[ | ]]
 .p156 [[ | ]]
 .p157 [[ | ]]
 .p157 [[ | ]]
 .p157 [[ | ]]
 .p159 [[ | ]]
 .p159 [[ | ]]

----
 .'''p161 Chapter 6 - The Mosquito Liberation Front'''
 .p161 [[ | ]]
 .p162 [[ | ]]
 .p163 [[ | ]]
 .p164 [[ | ]]
 .p165 [[ | ]]
 .p166 [[ | ]]
 .p167 [[ | ]]
 .p167 [[ | ]]
 .p169 [[ | ]]
 .p172 [[ | ]]
 .p173 [[ | ]]
 .p174 [[ | ]]
 .p175 [[ | ]]
 .p175 [[ | ]]
 .p175 [[ | ]]
 .p182 [[ | ]]
 .p183 [[ | ]]
 .p183 [[ | ]]
 .p184 [[ | ]]
 .p184 [[ | ]]
 .p186 [[ | ]]

----
 .'''p191 Chapter 7 - Nobel Prize Disease'''
 .p192 [[ | ]]
 .p192 [[ | ]]
 .p192 [[ | ]]
 .p195 [[ | ]]
 .p195 [[ | ]]
 .p196 [[ | ]]
 .p198 [[ | ]]
 .p199 [[ | ]]
 .p201 [[ | ]]
 .p202 [[ | ]]
 .p206 [[ | ]]

----
 .'''p213 Chapter 8 - Learning From the Past'''
 .p214 [[ | ]]
 .p214 [[ | ]]
 .p215 [[ | ]]
 .p216 [[ | ]]
 .p217 [[ | ]]
 .p219 [[ | ]]
 .p221 [[ | ]]
 .p222 [[ | ]]
 .p223 [[ | ]]
 .p224 [[ | ]]
 .p225 [[ | ]]
 .p226 [[ | ]]
 .p227 [[ | ]]
 .p228 [[ | ]]
 .p228 [[ | ]]
 .p228 [[ | ]]
 .p229 [[ | ]]
 .p230 [[ | ]]
 .p231 [[ | ]]
 .p234 [[ | ]]
 .p235 [[ | ]]
 .p235 [[ | ]]
 .p236 [[ | ]]
 .p236 [[ | ]]
 .p237 [[ | ]]
 .p237 [[ | ]]
 .p237 [[ | ]]
 .p238 [[ | ]]
 .p239 [[ | ]]
 .p239 [[ | ]]
 .p239 [[ | ]]
 .p240 [[ | ]]

----
 .p241 Epilogue
 .p241 [[ | ]]
Line 16: Line 224:
-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - Signs and Symptoms'''
 .p015

-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - Signs and Symptoms'''
 .p015

-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - Signs and Symptoms'''
 .p015

-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 1 - Signs and Symptoms'''
 .p015

------
  .'''Section II:. REDISCOVERING ONE ANOTHER'''
-----
 .'''p097 Chapter 6 - The (Social) Water is Just Fine'''
 .p097
----
 .p243 Acknowledgements
Line 38: Line 227:
-----
 .'''p114 Chapter 7 - Building Cultures of Trust'''
 .p114

-----
 .'''p015 Chapter 8 - The Fault is in Our Fault Lines'''
 .p015

------
  .'''Section III:. THE FUTURE OF HOPE'''
-----
 .'''p151 Chapter 9 - Building the World We Want'''
 .p097
 
-----
 .'''p168 Chapter 10 - The Optimism of Activism'''
 .p114

-----
 .'''p185 Chapter 11 - Our Common Fate'''
 .p015

-----
 .p200 Epilogue

-----
 .p205 Acknowledgements

-----
 .p209 Appendix A: A Practical Guide to Hopeful Skepticism

-----
 .p213 Appendix B: Evaluating the Evidence

-----
 .p217 Chapter Claim Ratings

-----
 .p225 Notes

-----
 .p263 Index

----
 .p245 Selected Bibliography
 .p245 [[ | ]]
 .p246 [[ | ]]
 .p247 [[ | ]]
 .p249 [[ | ]]
 .p253 [[ | ]]
 .p254 [[ | ]]
 .p258 [[ | ]]
 .p259 [[ | ]]
 .p260 [[ | ]]
 .p261 [[ | ]]
 .p261 [[ | ]]
 .p264 [[ | ]]
 .p266 [[ | ]]
 .p269 [[ | ]]

----
 .p273 About the Author

----
 .p275 Index

Pandora's Lab

Seven Stories of Science Gone Wrong

  • Paul A. Offit, M.D. . 2017 . 500 OFFIT 2017 . Hillsboro Library


  • p001 Introduction


  • p015 Chapter 1 - God's Own Medicine

  • p016 alpha-narcotine papaverine thebaine

  • p022 Alexander Wood invented first hypodermic needle 1853 to administer morphine (rather than orally), believed that injection would "cure the appetite" for morphine addiction.

    • "Pandora" repeats myth that morphine overdose injection killed his wife, who actually outlived him by 10 years.
  • p024 Heinrich Dreser responsible for aspirin and heroin and codeine at Bayer AG

  • p025 Eli Lilly "safe" heroin distributed over-the-counter without prescription in the US in 1900, JAMA "standard of care" in 1906

  • p025 1906 JAMA: heroin standard of care for many respiratory ailments; by 1910 doctors aware of addiction, use declined
  • p027 next, thebaine a different opium compound. oxycodone the synthetic form in 1916,

  • p028 Purdue OxyContin time release tablet releases immediate addictive dose if chewed


  • p041 Chapter 2 - The Great Margarine Mistake

  • p043 Ancel Keys urged fat restriction

  • po44 1977 McGovern report food guidelines authored by Nick Mottern non-scientist reporter

  • p048 The 1977 report conflated unhealthy saturated fats with healthy, essential unsaturated fats (some double bonds between carbons)

  • p050 margarine unhealthy trans-fats

  • p051 Cis-unsaturated fats (two adjacent "missing" hydrogens at a double carbon bond) are liquids because the molecules bend and don't stack into a solid
  • p052 Trans fat molecules straight and unhealthy

  • p053 Crisco Crystalized cottonseed oil, hydrogenated

  • p054 CSPI Center for Science in the Public Interest

  • p054 and NHSA(?) pushed trans-fats as a healthy alternative
  • p055 replacing trans-fats with other unsaturated fats reduced heart disease by 33% (or 53%)
  • p056 vLDL worse than LDL, HDL best

  • p056 Food and Additives Amendment grandfathered pre-1958 foods, Institute of Medicine petitioned transfat removal in 1994

  • p057 Harvard nutritionist Walter Willett recommended margarine in 1980s, "sending them to their graves prematurely"

  • p057 2006 FDA required trans-fats on nutrition labels
  • p058 products with less than 0.5g transfat can claim 0g transfat on the nutrition label
  • p058 avoid "partially hydrogenated vegetable oil on nutrition label
  • p059 "Welsh study showed exactly the opposite" (that trans-fat was bad)


  • p061 Chapter 3 - Blood From Air

  • p062 farming without artificial fertilizer feeds less than 4 billion people.
  • p063 Fritz Haber 1868-1934

    • Wife Clara chemist, first Phd for German woman, suicide after Fritz supervises chemical weapon attack

  • p066 1912 Germany imported 900,000 tonnes of nitrates, mostly from Chile, potential naval blockade
  • p067 University of Karlsruhe and BASF, more German Nobel Prizes

  • p068 N₂ triple bond "strongest in nature" 945 kJ/mol (natural carbon monoxide 1072 kJ/mol is 50-100 ppb)

  • p070 Robert Le Rossignol engineered first tabletop "Haber" process

  • p071 Output increase from 0.005% to 8% "logarithmically better" oopsie, should be "exponentially better"
  • p071 Industrial scaleup by Carl Bosch, founder of IG Farben

  • p072 by 1911, 8000 pounds of ammonia per day
  • p072 1913 Oppau plant produced 60,000 tons of ammonia per year

  • p073 "Today" 130 million tons of nitrogen fertilizer
  • p074 Ammonia Production Plants—A Review

  • p074 M.W. Kellogg 1960s most efficient ammonia manufacturing

  • p074 Chinese obesity, 30% of Beijing overweight
  • p075 Donaldson Louisiana largest nitrogen producing plant, 8 million tonnes per year
  • p075 dead zone in Gulf of Mexico larger than New Jersey

  • p076 excess nitrogen also from food animal manure
  • p077 1914 Germany invaded neutral Belgium, Haber and 90+ other German scientists signed manifesto defending the war
  • p078 1915 Haber produces 150 T/day ammonium nitrate explosive
  • p078 1917 Leuna plant produced 240,000 T/y

  • p079 Speer: If Allies had focused on destroying Leuna plant, WWII could have ended in eight weeks

  • p081 1916, Haber chief of Chemical Warfare Service, 2000 scientists
  • p081 chlorine gas, immediate death, heavier than air and spreads down into trenches
  • p081 violation of 1907 Hague Convention, signed by Germany

  • p082 Haber releases 150 tonnes of chlorine near 1915 Ypres, witnessed by future Nobel Prize winners Otto Hahn, Gustav Hertz, James Franck, and Hans Geiger

  • p083 Haber's chemist wife Clara, first Phd for German woman, suicide after Fritz supervises chemical weapon attack

  • p084

  • p085

  • p086

  • p086

  • p087

  • p088

  • p090

  • p091

  • p092

  • p094


  • p097 Chapter 4 America's Master Race

  • p097

  • p098

  • p098

  • p100

  • p101

  • p103

  • p104 Support

  • p105

  • p107

  • p107

  • p108

  • p109

  • p111

  • p112

  • p116

  • p118

  • p121

  • p121

  • p121

  • p122

  • p122

  • p122

  • p123

  • p124

  • p125

  • p125

  • p127

  • p128

  • p129


  • p131 Chapter 5 - Turning the Mind Inside Out

  • p132

  • p134

  • p135

  • p136

  • p138

  • p146

  • p147

  • p147

  • p148

  • p148

  • p148

  • p148

  • p149

  • p150

  • p151

  • p152

  • p152

  • p153

  • p153

  • p153

  • p154

  • p154

  • p155

  • p155

  • p156

  • p156

  • p157

  • p157

  • p157

  • p159

  • p159


  • p161 Chapter 6 - The Mosquito Liberation Front

  • p161

  • p162

  • p163

  • p164

  • p165

  • p166

  • p167

  • p167

  • p169

  • p172

  • p173

  • p174

  • p175

  • p175

  • p175

  • p182

  • p183

  • p183

  • p184

  • p184

  • p186


  • p191 Chapter 7 - Nobel Prize Disease

  • p192

  • p192

  • p192

  • p195

  • p195

  • p196

  • p198

  • p199

  • p201

  • p202

  • p206


  • p213 Chapter 8 - Learning From the Past

  • p214

  • p214

  • p215

  • p216

  • p217

  • p219

  • p221

  • p222

  • p223

  • p224

  • p225

  • p226

  • p227

  • p228

  • p228

  • p228

  • p229

  • p230

  • p231

  • p234

  • p235

  • p235

  • p236

  • p236

  • p237

  • p237

  • p237

  • p238

  • p239

  • p239

  • p239

  • p240


  • p241 Epilogue
  • p241


  • p243 Acknowledgements


  • p245 Selected Bibliography
  • p245

  • p246

  • p247

  • p249

  • p253

  • p254

  • p258

  • p259

  • p260

  • p261

  • p261

  • p264

  • p266

  • p269


  • p273 About the Author


  • p275 Index

PandorasLab (last edited 2026-05-15 06:01:03 by KeithLofstrom)